
He Cheated While I Grieved, So I Took Back My First Love
Chapter 2
The door swung open, and Ethan stumbled in with the smell of whiskey and cigarette smoke.
He fumbled for the light switch and missed it twice.
"Babe? Why are you sitting in the dark?"
"Turn it on," I said. "I want you to see this."
The overhead light snapped on. He squinted at me, his tie loose, his collar smeared with something pink.
I picked up the iPad and turned it toward him. The story was still looping. The blonde girl. His mouth on her temple. His hand sliding down her back.
Ethan's face went slack. Then he laughed, a nervous little huff.
"Okay. Okay, that's... that's not what it looks like."
"It looks like your hand is down her skirt."
"Lila..."
"Who is she?"
"Nobody. Just a girl from the mixer. Jenna. She's a junior." He rubbed his face hard with both palms. "We were all drinking. It was stupid. It didn't mean anything."
"You posted it, Ethan. You posted it twelve minutes after I called you about my grandmother."
He winced. For one second, I thought I saw real shame.
Then he dropped onto the arm of the couch and started talking.
"You don't know what it's like for me here. You really don't. Every day I'm smiling at people who don't care if I live or die. I'm networking, I'm studying, I'm faking it. I'm so tired, Lila. I'm so fucking lonely."
"You live with me."
"You know what I mean." He reached for my knee. I pulled it away. "It was one night. One stupid night. I wasn't thinking. Please. We've been through so much together."
I stared at him. His eyes were wet. His voice was shaking.
None of it was for me.
"You're lonely," I repeated.
"Yes."
"My grandmother died tonight, and you're telling me you're lonely."
He opened his mouth. Closed it.
I stood up. My legs felt strange, too light, like they belonged to someone else.
"We're done, Ethan."
"What?"
"We're breaking up."
I walked to the bedroom. He followed, talking the whole time.
"Lila, wait. You're upset. You're grieving. You shouldn't make decisions like this tonight."
I pulled his duffel bag out of the closet and started throwing things into it. His shirts. His running shoes. The cologne he wore every day, the one I bought him for Christmas.
"Are you serious right now?" His voice climbed. "Stop. Lila, stop it."
I carried the bag to the front door and dropped it. Then I went back for his laptop charger, his textbooks, the stupid gray hoodie he'd left on the bathroom floor that morning.
The pile grew by the door. He watched it like he was watching a car crash.
"This is insane," he said. "You're not thinking straight."
"I've never thought straighter."
"Two years, Lila. Two years. Do you remember our first winter here? When the heat broke and we slept in our coats? When we split one bowl of ramen because we couldn't afford groceries?" He stepped closer. His voice dropped to that soft, careful tone he used when he wanted something. "We only had each other. Nobody else in this whole city. That has to mean something."
"It did."
"It still does."
"No." I tossed his toothbrush onto the pile. "It meant something until tonight."
"You need me right now. You're alone. Your family is on the other side of the world." He reached for me. "Come here. Let me hold you. You'll feel better, I swear."
His arms wrapped around me before I could step back. His chest pressed against my cheek. I smelled her perfume on his shirt. Sweet. Vanilla.
Something inside me snapped.
I shoved him so hard he slammed into the wall.
"Don't touch me."
He blinked, stunned. "Lila..."
"Don't you dare touch me with her all over you."
"I'm trying to help you!"
"You're trying to help *yourself*." I yanked the front door open. Cold hallway air rushed in. "Get out."
"It's two in the morning. Where am I supposed to go?"
"Ask Jenna."
His jaw tightened. For a second, his eyes went hard, and I saw the real Ethan underneath the tears.
"You're going to regret this," he said quietly.
"Get. Out."
I kicked the duffel bag into the hall. Then the books. Then the hoodie.
He stood there in the doorway, swaying a little.
"I love you," he said.
I shut the door in his face and turned the deadbolt.
He knocked once. Twice. Then nothing.
My phone started buzzing before I even made it back to the couch.
*Lila please open the door*
*I'm sorry. I'm so sorry*
*I was drunk. I didn't mean any of it*
*You're the only one who ever understood me*
*Remember the ramen? Remember the heater? I can't lose that*
I read that last one twice. The irony almost made me laugh. He could. He already had.
*Please. I'll sit out here all night if I have to*
*Your grandma would want us to work this out*
I flipped the phone face-down on the cushion.
That one hurt worse than the video.
The apartment was so quiet I could hear the clock. The lamp still buzzed. His coffee mug sat on the counter, half full, a ring of brown stuck to the inside.
Everywhere I glanced, there was something. His sneakers by the radiator. My grandma's face on the fridge, smiling from a photo he'd taken on our video call last spring.
*"Is he good to you, Lila?"*
My chest squeezed tight. I pressed a hand flat against my ribs and tried to breathe. In. Out. It didn't help. The air felt thick, like the walls were leaning in.
The phone buzzed again. And again. And again.
If I stayed here, I would sit on this couch until sunrise. I would replay every text. Every phone call. Every *love you, gotta go.*
I would drown in this room.
I grabbed my coat off the hook and checked the peephole. The hallway was empty. Just his duffel bag, abandoned against the wall. He'd left. Of course he had.
I didn't let myself think about where he went.
There was a bar two blocks down. Murphy's. Dark wood, cheap whiskey, nobody who knew my name.
That was exactly what I needed.
I stepped out into the street, and the cold hit me first.
Then the rain.
It came down thin and icy, the kind of October rain that crawled under your collar and stayed there. Taxis hissed past, their headlights blurring on the wet asphalt.
I pulled my coat tight around me and tucked my chin down.
My phone buzzed in my pocket one more time.
I didn't check it.
I just walked into the rain, toward the red glow of a sign I'd passed a hundred times and never once gone inside.
Tonight, I didn't care who I'd meet there.
I just didn't want to be alone with the ghosts.
You may also like





