
He Cheated While I Grieved, So I Took Back My First Love
Chapter 3
Murphy's was louder than I expected for a Tuesday at two in the morning.
A jukebox was playing something about a broken truck. Two guys near the dartboard were arguing over a score. The air smelled like spilled beer and wet wool.
I slid onto a stool at the far end of the bar and peeled off my soaked coat.
The bartender had a gray beard and a towel slung over his shoulder. He gave me one look and set down a napkin.
"Rough night?"
"Whiskey. Neat."
"That a yes?"
"That's a whiskey."
He poured it without another word.
The first one burned all the way down. The second one went easier. By the third, my fingers had stopped shaking, and the jukebox sounded far away, like it was playing in another room.
My phone buzzed against the bar top. *Ethan.*
I declined it.
It buzzed again. *Ethan.*
I flipped it over and pushed the empty glass toward the bartender.
"Another."
"You eating anything tonight, kid?"
"My grandmother used to ask me that."
He paused with the bottle in his hand. "Used to?"
I didn't answer. He poured anyway, a little lighter this time.
I wrapped both hands around the glass and stared into it. Grandma's kitchen. The steam from her soup. The way she always tapped my wrist twice when she wanted me to slow down and listen.
*"Eat first, Lila. Sadness is easier on a full stomach."*
My eyes stung. I blinked hard and lifted my chin.
That was when I saw him.
Across the curve of the bar, under the green glow of a beer sign. Dark hair, longer than it used to be. A sharp jaw with a shadow of stubble. A thin scar through his left eyebrow that hadn't been there before.
But the eyes were the same. Gray, like the sky right before snow.
Silas.
The glass slipped in my grip. Whiskey sloshed over my knuckles.
Three years. Three years since he stopped answering my calls. Since his number went dead. Since I stood outside his empty apartment with my fist still raised to knock, and his landlord told me he'd moved out in the middle of the night.
No note. No goodbye. Nothing.
I'd spent the whole next year looking for him in every crowd. Then I applied to every school I could find that was as far from home as possible. New York. A new city, where nothing would remind me of him.
And here he was. In a dive bar two blocks from my apartment.
He was staring right back at me.
His face drained of color. His mouth parted. Then something else crossed his features, something heavy that made his shoulders sink.
Guilt.
He pushed off his stool.
*No. No, no, no.*
Every muscle in my back went rigid. I set the glass down too hard. The bartender glanced over.
Silas walked around the bar slowly, like he was afraid I'd run. He stopped a few feet away.
"Lila."
His voice was lower now. Rougher.
"Don't," I said.
"I just..."
"I said don't."
He swallowed. His hand twitched at his side, like he wanted to reach for me and knew better.
"I didn't know you were in New York."
"Why would you? You'd have to have asked."
He flinched.
My phone buzzed again on the bar. The screen lit up between us. *Ethan.* Then a text underneath: *Please pick up. I'm worried about you.*
Silas's gaze dropped to it. Then back up to my face.
"Is that someone I should be worried about?"
I laughed. It came out loud and bright, way too bright, and the guys by the dartboard turned to look. I couldn't stop. I pressed the back of my wrist against my mouth until it passed.
"You?" I said. "*You* want to worry about me? That's funny, Silas. That's really funny."
He didn't smile. He just watched me, his jaw working.
"You've been crying."
"My grandma died tonight."
The words dropped like a stone. His whole body went still.
"Mrs. Lin," he said quietly. "She used to give me those sesame cookies. In the red tin."
My throat closed. I'd forgotten that. She'd liked him. She'd asked about him for months after he disappeared, until I told her to stop.
"Yeah," I managed. "Those."
"I'm so sorry, Lila."
He stepped closer. I slid off my stool and moved back, putting it between us like a fence.
"Stay over there."
He stopped. Raised both hands a little. "Okay."
"Why are you here?"
"I live nearby. Sometimes I don't sleep."
"That's not what I meant." My voice cracked, and I hated it. "Why did you leave? Three years ago. Why did you just... vanish?"
Silas looked away. He fixed his eyes on the row of bottles behind the bar, like the answer was written on one of the labels.
"It's complicated."
"Try me."
"Lila..."
"I waited for you." I gripped the edge of the stool so hard my nails bit into the vinyl. "I called you every day for two months. I went to the police. I thought you were *dead*, Silas. Do you understand that? I thought somebody had killed you and dumped you in a river."
His eyes snapped back to mine. They were wet.
"I know."
"You *know*?"
"I heard. Later." His voice broke on the word. "I heard what you went through. And I hated myself for it."
"Then tell me why."
"I had reasons."
"Reasons."
"Real ones. Ones that weren't about you. I swear to you, none of it was about you."
"That's not an answer."
"It's the only one I'm allowed to give."
*Allowed.* The word hung there, strange and cold.
"Allowed by who?"
He pressed his lips together. Shook his head once.
My phone buzzed again. And again. The screen kept flashing Ethan's name like a heartbeat.
"Unbelievable." I grabbed my coat off the stool. "Every man in my life tonight has a story he won't finish."
"Lila, wait."
"Last call!" the bartender barked. "We're closing up, folks."
I threw two twenties on the bar. My hands were steady now. Steadier than they'd been all night.
Silas reached into his jacket. "Let me at least give you my number..."
"You had my number. For three years."
That one landed. I watched it hit him. He lowered his hand.
"I'm sorry," he said again. Softer this time. Like he'd said it a thousand times to an empty room and was only now saying it out loud.
I didn't answer. I pushed through the crowd toward the door.
Behind me, I heard his stool scrape. He was following. I walked faster.
The door swung open, and the rain hit me like a wall. It wasn't thin anymore. It was pouring, sheets of it hammering the sidewalk, rushing in the gutters, drumming on the awning over my head.
I stopped under the dripping edge and tugged my collar up.
Then I froze.
Someone was standing on the curb, soaked to the skin. His hair was plastered to his forehead. His shirt clung to his chest. The pink smear on his collar had run into a pale stain.
Ethan.
He looked up. His eyes locked on mine, red-rimmed and desperate.
"I knew you'd come here," he said. "I've been waiting."
Behind me, the bar door creaked open again.
And Ethan's gaze slid past my shoulder, to the man stepping out after me.
His face changed.
You may also like





