
The Hockey Captain Chose Her
Chapter 3
I woke up on Sunday morning to my phone vibrating so relentlessly against my nightstand that it nearly rattled itself onto the hardwood floor.
Sunlight filtered through the blinds of my tiny off-campus studio—the place I had retreated to at midnight after Kaelen insisted on walking me all the way to my third-floor door, checking the deadbolt himself, and leaving his black-and-silver #91 varsity jacket draped over my chair before disappearing into the sleet.
Groaning, I reached for my iPhone. The screen was buried under an avalanche of notifications: 94 missed calls. 312 unread messages. 14,000+ mentions on TikTok and X.
With a knot tightening in my stomach, I tapped open the trending tab on X first.
The number two trending sports topic across the entire East Coast was #SectionFourGirl. Right below it was #Thorne91.
I clicked the top video, posted by Barstool College Hockey with two million views in eight hours.
It was a split-screen edit. The first half showed the Jumbotron replay from last night—Brett hauling Tiffany Sloane over the dasher boards while my shocked, tear-streaked face stood frozen three feet behind them in Section Four. My chest pinched with a sharp phantom ache, until the video cut to the second half, filmed by a credentialed sideline photographer in the players' tunnel.
In crisp 4K resolution, the clip showed Kaelen Thorne stepping between me and Brett like a six-foot-four bodyguard, wrapping his captain's jacket around my shoulders, and staring Brett down while I pulled off the crimson #14 practice jersey and dropped it right on Brett's skates.
The caption read: Briarwood's captain fumbled a dime for a cheerleader, and St. Jude's Kaelen Thorne scooped her up in under sixty seconds. Next Saturday's National Final just got PERSONAL.
The comments section was an absolute warzone:
@PuckBunnyDaily: Wait, look at the way Kaelen Thorne tucked her into his side in that tunnel. That man hasn't looked at a girl once in three years at St. Jude and he's staring at her like he'd commit a felony for her!!
@FrozenFourInsider: That's Clara Vance, Briarwood's head student PT and film analyst. Rumor has it she dated Miller on the low since freshman year and rehabbed his knee. Miller is an generational idiot.
@WolfpackHockey91: OUR CAPTAIN SAID "MY GIRL NOW." PUT HER IN SILVER AND BLACK IMMEDIATELY.
Before I could scroll further, my screen lit up with an incoming call: Brett Miller.
I hit decline and opened our text thread, where forty-seven consecutive messages from Brett were waiting:
Brett [1:14 AM]: Clara, pick up the damn phone. What the hell were you thinking pulling a stunt like that with Kaelen Thorne in front of the press?!
Brett [1:42 AM]: You know Tiffany's dad is paying for half the team's charter flights and sits on the board with my sports agency! She grabbed me first, I was hyped up on overtime adrenaline, I couldn't just shove her off on live TV!
Brett [3:09 AM]: Why aren't you at my place? My left knee is stiff as hell after overtime and I need ultrasound therapy before noon film session.
Brett [8:15 AM]: Answer me, Clara. Delete whatever photos are going around and issue a statement saying Thorne just lent you a coat because you tripped. Be at the Briarwood training room at 10:00 AM with my scouting binder or we're going to have a real problem.
I stared at that 3:09 AM text until a cold, incredulous laugh escaped my throat.
Even after humiliating me in front of twelve thousand people and shoving his tongue down Tiffany Sloane's throat on the Jumbotron, Brett's biggest concern at three in the morning was that his left knee was stiff and nobody was there to rub anti-inflammatory gel into his scar tissue.
And he wanted my scouting binder.
The heavy black three-ring binder currently sitting on my kitchen table—the one containing sixty pages of handwritten play diagrams, zone-entry tendencies, and penalty-kill breakdowns I had spent the entire semester compiling on my own unpaid time.
A sudden knock sounded at my apartment door.
My pulse spiked. If Brett had the nerve to show up here—
My phone buzzed with a text from an unknown number I had saved at 12:15 AM under Kaelen Thorne:
Kaelen: Don't bother looking through the peephole with a kitchen knife. It's me. And I brought breakfast.
I exhaled a breath I didn't realize I was holding, padded barefoot across the floorboards in my oversized sweatpants, and pulled the door open.
Kaelen stood in my narrow hallway looking like he had stepped straight out of an athletic streetwear editorial. He wore a fitted charcoal henley that stretched tight across his broad chest and tattooed forearms, dark jeans, and black boots. In one hand, he held a brown paper bakery bag; in the other, two iced green teas—iced matcha with oat milk and a single pump of vanilla, my exact order.
"How did you know what I drink?" I asked, blinking up at him.
"You carry that exact cup into the arena before every game," Kaelen replied without missing a beat, stepping inside and shutting the door behind him with his boot. His silver eyes swept over my face, checking for fresh tears before softening fractionally. "Did you sleep?"
"Four hours," I admitted, accepting the cup as our fingers brushed, sending a traitorously warm tingle up my wrist. "Before my phone exploded. Have you seen the internet?"
"My group chat has sent me the tunnel video nineteen times since seven this morning," Kaelen said dryly, setting the bakery bag on my small counter. His gaze dropped to the thick black binder sitting beside my laptop, and then to the open text thread from Brett still glowing on my phone screen. His jaw flexed, a muscle ticking beneath his cheek. "He's demanding you show up at the Briarwood training facility at ten."
"I need to go anyway," I said, lifting my chin. "My certification logbook and my personal equipment are in the trainers' locker room, and I have to turn in my intern keycard to the head athletic director so I can transfer my clinical hours to the university hospital."
"And the binder?" Kaelen asked, nodding toward the sixty pages of handwritten hockey intelligence.
A slow, razor-sharp smile curved my lips. I walked over to the table, snapped open the metal rings of the binder, and pulled out every single page of my custom opponent breakdowns, leaving only the standard NCAA public stat sheets that any freshman could print off the league website.
"Brett wants his binder back," I said smoothly. "He can have the binder. The brain that wrote what was inside it doesn't work for Briarwood anymore."
Something dark and fiercely approving flared in Kaelen's storm-gray eyes. "Ten o'clock at the Briarwood Athletic Complex?"
"Yes. Don't worry, I can handle Brett on my own—"
"You don't have to," Kaelen said, reaching into the canvas duffel slung over his shoulder and pulling out a crisp, freshly pressed St. Jude Wolves jersey—jet-black with metallic silver trim, the captain's C on the chest, and THORNE 91 stitched across the back shoulders. "If we're doing this, Clara, we're not hiding in hallways. Put your boots on. I'm driving you into the Bulldogs' den myself."
You may also like





