
My Husband Replaced My Baby with His Mistress’s Child
Chapter 4
I carried him back to the nursery that night.
Harley was already there. She'd let herself in with the key Alessandro had given her—the key I hadn't known existed until I found it on the PI's inventory list. She stood by the crib in her black coat, not yet removed, like she'd never planned to stay.
I didn't say anything. I just held the baby out.
She took him. Both hands, that same instinct I'd watched at the accident scene. She pressed her face to his hair and closed her eyes for exactly one second.
I walked out.
Down the hall, past the kitchen where my mother's chicken soup still sat in a container in the fridge. Past the study with the locked drawer. Into the elevator, down to the parking garage, where the fluorescent lights buzzed and the air smelled like concrete and motor oil.
I called Maisie.
She picked up on the second ring. I didn't say hello.
'It's time,' I said.
Four minutes. That was all it took. When I hung up, I sat in my car in the empty garage and stared at the gray wall in front of me. No tears. I'd used those up in the nursery weeks ago, in the dark, for a daughter I never got to hold.
I opened my banking app and began moving money.
Not all of it. Not yet. Just the pieces I could lift without making noise. A woman learning to pack light.
***
The funeral was on a Friday.
Gray sky, bare trees, the kind of cold that gets into your collar no matter how you dress. The cemetery in Queens was quiet except for the priest's voice and the sound of someone's umbrella turning inside out in the wind.
Alessandro stood beside me in his good coat. He checked his phone twice during the service. The second time, I watched his thumb move across the screen with the focused efficiency of a man answering something important.
I looked back at the caskets.
He left after forty minutes. Kissed my temple. Said he had a call he couldn't move. Said I should come home soon, not stand out in the cold too long.
I nodded.
The last mourner—my mother's friend from her book club, a small woman in a purple scarf who had cried the entire time—squeezed my hand and left. And then it was just me.
I stood there until the cemetery workers appeared at a respectful distance, waiting.
Then I reached into my coat pocket and took out the small stone I'd carried from the apartment. Smooth gray granite, no bigger than my palm. I'd had it engraved at a shop in Midtown two days ago, cash, no name on my receipt.
*For the one who never arrived. Loved before she was lost.*
I set it in the ground beside my parents' headstones. Pressed it level with both hands. The soil was cold and slightly damp.
I stayed crouched there for a moment, my hand flat on the earth.
I thought about my mother's kitchen at midnight, the blender running, the smell of ginger and ashwagandha and whatever else the naturopath had prescribed. Three years of that. Three years of her believing she was helping me. Alessandro collecting the jars from our refrigerator shelf. Driving them somewhere else.
I thought about my father, who always drove because that was simply what he did.
I stood up.
'Never again,' I said to the wind.
Not a prayer. Not a promise to them. A statement of fact, the way you'd read a number off a page.
I walked back to the car alone.
***
I went to Ray's on a Sunday.
The West Village café was exactly as it had always been—the fogged window, the small copper bell above the door, the smell of espresso and something baking. Ray was behind the counter in his green apron, and when he saw me his whole face opened up.
'There she is.' He spread his arms wide. 'Miss Sugar. Where have you been hiding?'
'Around,' I said. 'Busy winter.'
'Mr. Espresso coming? I'll pull a double.'
I smiled. It fit my face the way a well-worn coat fits—automatically, without effort. 'He sends his regards.'
'Tell him I'm offended.' Ray was already moving. 'The usual?'
'Just black,' I said. 'No sugar.'
He paused. Half a beat. Then he nodded and turned to the machine.
I took the window table. Outside, the street was wet from an earlier rain, and the afternoon light came through the glass at a low angle and made everything look like a photograph of itself. I remembered sitting here with Alessandro watching the rain, his hand over mine, laughing about something I couldn't remember anymore. I tried. I genuinely tried to pull up what we'd been laughing about.
Nothing came.
Ray set the cup down. 'You okay, sweetheart?'
'Better than I've been in years,' I said.
He patted the table twice and went back to his counter.
I drank the coffee slowly. It was bitter and clean and tasted exactly like what it was. When I finished, I left a twenty under the saucer and stood.
I didn't look back at the table.
I didn't look back at all.
You may also like





